Do You Shift for Yourself?

Do You Shift for Yourself?

By Patrick F. Cannon

Last week, I wrote about the now rare wringer clothes washer, and mentioned that you could still actually buy one. This week, I thought I’d write about another archaic throwback – cars with manual transmissions. Although it gets more difficult every year, you can still get one.

            Of the 19 cars I’ve owned in my lifetime, six had manual transmissions: two VW Beetles, a Volvo station wagon, Fiat sports coupe, Ford Escort hatchback, and a Ford Probe GT (my favorite). Before I owned my own cars, I occasionally drove some friend’s beater, which almost always had a three-speed column shifter. I learned to drive on one of these. While in the army, I regularly drove a ¾-ton truck; a few times a 2-1/2 ton truck; jeeps of various vintages; and even an International Scout, which was used for guard duty at Fr. Erwin, California. All, of course, had manual transmissions.

            As far as I can recall, the first car with an automatic transmission I ever saw was in a pristine Pre-World War II  Oldsmobile sedan that picked us up when we were hitchhiking to caddy at the Edgewood Country Club near Pittsburgh. This would have been in the early 1950s. While automatic transmissions were more widely available by then, they were still an expensive option. They also provided poorer gas mileage, and took longer to accelerate than a well-handled car with a manual transmission.

            Automatic transmissions are now standard equipment and none of the above is true. To provide maximum flexibility in today’s generally smaller engines, 8-speed transmissions are common, but as many as 12 are available. Some have various modes, depending on how you’re driving. Most common would be “economy” or “sport.” The latter would delay shifts for maximum acceleration. My BMW can be shifted manually by moving the shifter to the left; you can then shift through five speeds at any RPM point you choose. I rarely do this, as most of my driving is done on level terrain, on expressways and city streets.

            While I concede there is a certain pleasure in driving a sporty car with manual transmission on an empty road, this happens so rarely that it’s not worth the trouble of constantly shifting gears in city driving. If I had the extra dough, and the room, I confess I would like nothing better than to have a Morgan Plus 6 (look it up) to tool around the hinterlands of New England of Appalachia (or even parts of Illinois).

            Even the most sophisticated race cars – Formula 1 – do not require the driver to tramp down with his left foot on a clutch pedal to change gears. He (there are no women currently) simply uses a steering-wheel-mounted paddle to change gears, a system that is also becoming available on passenger cars. As with most systems on cars today, all of this is controlled by computers.

            Speaking of computers, who would actually wish to return to the days of the regular tune up? In the “good old days,” you would bring your car to a mechanic every 10,000 miles or so for a required tune up, which consisted of changing distributer points (again, if you’re a youngster, look it up), installing new spark plugs, cleaning and adjusting the carburetor, changing the oil and filter, greasing running gear and suspension components, and adjusting the timing with a gadget called a timing light. When you picked up your car, you would expect it to run once again like a fine watch.

            I once took a course to learn how to do all of this myself, but never really used the knowledge because my next car had computerized systems. People who own and cherish classic and collector cars often still have and use these skills. Of course, some day most cars will be electric, and have no transmissions at all. We’re also told they will drive themselves. While I don’t miss shifting gears, that’s where I think I might draw the line. I can just see Comrade Putin directing his minions to cause chaos on our highways (or at least more than we already have).

Copyright 2021, Patrick F. Cannon

5 thoughts on “Do You Shift for Yourself?

  1. One possible advantage to driving a manual is the likelihood that modern thieves won’t know how to drive it.

    I learned to drive a stick on a VW Beetle, graduated to a Honda Accord hatchback and later a Ford Fiesta, Honda Civic hatch, VW Jetta, Mazda 626ES, Subaru Forester and a 2004 Subaru WRX, which I still drive to carve up the back roads. The WRX has become a bit of a cult car. Mine is bone stock, a rare example, as the vast majority of these cars were modified beyond recognition and raced to disintegration. People, usually young people, occasionally stop and ask me about it. One fellow even took a picture of it. I certainly don’t fit the profile of the typical owner, but I figure it’s never too late to change the demographic.

    My other cars were all automatics, including the turbo-charged Forester XT Jill mostly drives. It has a continuously variable transmission (CVT) which dispenses with gears altogether in favor of variable width pulleys connected by a flexible belt (don’t ask). Acceleration is therefore seamless, though Subaru provides computer settings that mimic gear changes and even allow the driver to shift manually with paddle shifters. Really superfluous and a waste of time.

    My gripe with automatics is they deny your self-expression. Newer cars have mostly negated the driver’s individual personality. They have minds of their own and prefer to ignore you. They are appliances built by robots for consumers who would rather fiddle with touch screens (the devil’s work!) than operate a motor vehicle. Electric cars are the future, even self-driving ones. Plug in, switch on, dumb down.

    The Morgan Plus Six — retro styling, modern BMW engine — reminds me just a bit of the Lotus Seven S II club racer that was used in the classic and unique TV series from the late 1960s, The Prisoner, starring Patrick McGoohan, a car the protagonist claims to have built himself, with his bare hands. In fact, as the car lacks flashing indicators, the protagonist even signals his turns by hand. Now that car exemplifies unmistakable individuality. It does not have an automatic transmission.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Truth be told, nothing more pleasurable than shifting for yourself on any of a number of less-travelled back roads of this great land. I mentioned the Morgan, but a Mazda Miata would do almost as well. My BMW lacks a touch screen. I plan to keep it a bit longer.


  2. I’d probably get a Miata if it were a bit larger. A new WRX with manual has been announced, but it looks like a car in search of an identity, part family sedan, part crossover, part track racer, with a huge touch screen smack dab in the middle of the dashboard and a conformist styling to blend in with the Hondas, Nissans and Toyotas of this world. Obviously designed by a committee for the global market. Something for everybody. But as the adage goes, if everybody were somebody, nobody would be anybody!

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s