Field of Dreams

By Patrick F. Cannon

My friend and fellow Northwestern University graduate Ed Swanson kindly invited me to join him at last Saturday’s football game at the new Ryan Field in Evanston. It was a lovely day, and the Wildcats beat Rutgers 42-14. They are now 6-1 and nationally ranked number 20.  The new field is a wonderful venue, with great sight lines, comfortable seats, modern amenities, and elevators for us folks of advanced years! The old stadium, also named Ryan Field,  had none of this modern stuff.

Much of the cost of the new stadium came from Northwestern graduates Pat and Shirley Ryan, who have given nearly $900 million to the school over the years. The University of Chicago, founded with Rockefeller money in the late 1800s, has recently benefitted from  $300 million gifts from David Booth, and $125 million from Ken Griffin.

In addition to gifts to these and other Chicago universities, you can credit philanthropy with the building, expansion, and operations of Chicago adornments like the Art Institute, Chicago Symphony, Field Museum, Shedd Aquarium, Adler Planetarium, and Griffin Museum of Science and Industry (Ken Griffin gave them $125 million in 2019). That museum was originally financed by a 1926 gift from then Sears’s Chairman Julius Rosenwald, that would amount to $135 million in today’s money.

Every great American university and city would have a similar story to tell. In addition to those mentioned above, notable current major donors include billionaires Bill Gates and his former wife Melinda, Warren Buffet, Michael Bloomberg, and members of the Walton family of Walmart fame. They may be exceptions to their fellow billionaires – Forbes magazine reports that 75 percent of them give less than 5ive percent of their annual income to non-profit institutions and charities. (Although dealing in thousands rather than billions(!), I donated approximately 12 percent of my taxable income last year to cultural and charitable groups.)

(It goes without saying – but I’ll do it anyway – that not everyone agrees to the merits of every tax-exempt organization. Pro-life people would never donate to Planned Parenthood, for example. And I’m sure that not everyone loves the Salvation Army, as I do. Donors get to choose their causes. By the way, donations to politicians aren’t deductible, for obvious reasons. Why encourage them?).

President Trump in recent years has donated only his $500,000 salary, although it’s unclear which Federal agency receives it. However, he is much more generous with your tax money. On October 8, I checked my bank account and saw that it had been credited with $90 from the Social Security Administration. Confused, I went online and found it was meant to offset some of my Medicare costs. Although my yearly healthcare costs exceed $10,000, the $90 was welcome.

Last Friday, I finally got a personal letter from President Trump dated October 8 taking credit for the largess. Due to the efficiency of his Postal Service, it only took 15 days to find me.  The president’s generosity is only costing the taxpayers $2 billion. If his offer to pay voters $5,000 each if Republicans retain control of Congress actually transpires, we’ll have to pony up more than $850 billion (if limited to registered voters).

The president’s generosity with other people’s money is legendary. Despite his boasted personal wealth, he even managed to get his supporters to raise funds to pay his legal fees. None of his six bankruptcies were personal, and he is famous for stiffing creditors, including poor Rudy Guiliani, who did have to declare personal bankruptcy when Trump refused to pay his legal fees, no doubt because  Rudy had failed to overturn the 2020 election.

I was a bit disappointed by the letter though. It went on too long to allow for the president’s usual jumbo signature. It’s only 3/8 of an inch high. And since it’s printed, I wonder if it’s even valid?

Copyright 2026, Patrick F. Cannon

3 thoughts on “Field of Dreams”

  1. Wealth tax proponents seem to forget the social benefits of billionaire philanthropy, or at least see it as an opportunity.

    Not every billionaire employs his wealth in positive ways. George Soros seems intent on undermining democratic institutions and sowing social unrest, for twisted reasons few can comprehend.

    People often think of non-profits as unsullied by the corruptive influences of capitalism, a notion far from the truth. Many are quite wealthy (witness Harvard University) and many that can’t raise money on their own (so-called NGOs) are funded by the government. And sadly some are outright fraudulent.

    We also donate about 10-12% of our annual income, specifically to educational, environmental and charitable organizations like the Salvation Army. We never give to politicians or political causes.

    Charitable giving is a great American tradition. Anyone regardless of income can give. Of course, the amount one gives is discretionary. This applies equally to people of modest means and billionaires.

    Billionaire Trump donates his presidential salary. It’s his money and up to him, not you or me or Bernie Sanders, how he spends it.

    Marxists think rich people should give more, from each according to his ability, and if the individual doesn’t do so willingly, he should be forced to do it, which is a very different principle from voluntary charity. But Marxists are great moralizers, especially when the money is to them and not from them.

    Government spending comes exclusively from taxes, tariffs, fees, borrowing, printing, currency manipulations and various accounting tricks and ways, but always from other people. This fact may be why Democrats love big government. They see other people’s money as their money.

    A local example. In Mayberry, the Dems created an uproar over the state’s school voucher policy. Public school supporters claimed it amounted to stealing what was rightfully theirs, and made protest signs proclaiming it at the farmers’ market. How easy to forget where money comes from and who owns it.

    I don’t care much for Trump’s $5000 “dividend” (I didn’t get a letter.) Past presidents (Bush, Biden) gave people cash ostensibly to stimulate the economy. It didn’t work.

    The Medicare and ACA rebates are meant to compensate for excessive charges. We all know this is one way for governments to garner votes, and they all do it under various virtuous-sounding pretenses. I’d be happy for Medicare cost relief.

    I’d like to see my tax money applied to programs that work well and accomplish results, but I realize it’s a triumph of hope over experience. Maybe they should just spend less to begin with (another hopeless wish). That’s how it is when spending other people’s money. There’s no incentive for restraint.

    In the unlikely event I get a $5000 government “dividend”, it’s going to private charities, or maybe Steve’s fine wine and sports car fund. We’ll see when the check arrives.

    In the past 12 years or so, Indiana, having received more tax revenue than it needed, twice returned the overcharge, no strings attached, across the board and on principle You could say this refund was a cynical political tactic to get votes.

    If so, I favor it!

    Like

    1. I’m waiting for a politician who actually spends less of our dough, rather than just promising to! Another vain hope. By the way, we do get some election ads from Indiana. One warns that one of the candidates wants to turn Indiana into Illinois!

      Like

Leave a Reply